Wildly effective SEO, custom development, & no-B.S. technical consulting — at your service.

There’s more to SEO than you might think

Make search engines fall in love with your site.

Don’t let search problems hamstring your success

First, some bad news:

Technical search engine optimization (SEO) lags about 4-5 years behind development best practices.

Why? You can blame the trickle-down effect (no, not that one). Web development leads SEO, so there’s often a delay between what’s new and effective on the development front, and discovering effective search engine optimization practices to support that development.

The good news is that as your crack team of SEO + development, we don’t fall prey to that lag.

SEO has multiple faces. Like diamonds. Or Joan Rivers.

Which face will you stare into today?

Technical SEO

It’s not sexy, but its impact sure is.

Technical SEO goes far beyond surface-level SEO (like updating meta tags or adding in image alt tags). Problems (or even just forgetting to update certain spots) in your website backend can actually affect your search rankings.

Just a few of the issues we commonly find in our SEO audits:

Site security issues

Secure socket layer (SSL) encryption is no longer just a “nice-to-have,” by the way. Search engines lay the smackdown on unsecured sites.

Pages not ranking in search

Or occasionally even worse, the wrong pages ranking.

Poorly configured robots.txt

Did you know one wrong character in this teeny file can keep searchers from seeing ALL your pages’ meta descriptions?

URL and redirect issues

Let’s not even get into what happens when somebody mucks up your site migration and loses all the search authority your pages have built over years…


"We have used multiple SEO services in the past but most of them were cookie cutter and had the same path of thinking. We signed up with Polymath because we wanted a different approach to automotive SEO, we wanted someone who wasn’t doing the exact same thing and Polymath was able to do just that. Right off the bat we started with fixing issues in the code of the website, which no other SEO service we used even mentioned. That is when I knew we would be in good hands with Shelby and Polymath."

Steven Cianciolo - Stephen Automall Centre

Local Search Optimization

If your business runs a physical location (or two, or eight), then local search optimization is probably a big priority for you. Put simply, local SEO makes it easier for searchers near you to actually FIND you. Good local SEO involves a lot of factors, some straightforward and others agonizingly detailed:

Detailed, up-to-date business listings on Google, Bing, and social media

Claiming these is just step 1. Filling them out with photos and info for potential searchers is step 2. Keeping them accurate and consistent with each other is step 3, more commonly known as “galaxy brain”.

Local citations

Including business directories (yes, people still use these), related sites, and location-tied social platforms that carry more weight than general directories.

Reviews & responses

It’s not enough just to have reviews. You’ve gotta have a lot of them, AND you’ve got to respond to the jerks who decide to take their bad day out on your business.

Inbound link diversity & quality

In the search engines’ eyes, if your business is the real deal, lots of respected sites will link to it.

A whole bunch of other things

Domain authority, keyword and structured data optimization, localized content, proximity of the searcher, and more — We could explain them all on this page, but it’d be quicker and more rewarding for both of us if you just grab your free SEO audit now.

Mystery Traffic Loss from Penalties & Other Issues

From our very first time-out in Pre-K, to the NFL’s more recent spate of absolutely garbage blown calls, we’ve always hated penalties.

These days, we reserve our vitriol for search engine penalties: AKA when a human reviewer at Google decides to manually reduce your site’s visibility in the rankings. There’s a laundry list of site issues that can bring on manual penalties, from sneaky redirects and “unnatural” links to hidden text and keyword stuffing.

If you’ve started to lose traffic for penalties or other reasons and you’re not sure why, it’s time for an audit. Technical issues like poor site architecture, thin or duplicate content, and non-mobile-optimized pages can all cause a dip in your site traffic.

We’ll help you figure out what happened, and how to fix it.


"Working with Shelby at Polymath has been a great partnership. Shelby knows SEO very well and can easily communicate it to those that are not as familiar with it. They came to us with new strategies to grow our online presence and executed those strategies in a timely manner. We saw measurable results that generated true ROI"

Chad Beville - Reveel


  • A crucial part of your branding and marketing. If your company were a piece of toast, SEO would be the avocado. Things just don’t work without it.
  • Always striving to better match your offer to your users’ needs
  • A combination of technical (hard) factors and content (soft) factors


  • Voodoo
  • Sorcery
  • A douchey exploitation of “weaknesses in the algorithm”
  • Something your smart nephew can pick up in a week or two

Getting results from SEO takes expertise, attention to detail & consistency

Every discipline in the marketing industry has its experts and charlatans, its enduring wisdom and “quick hacks”.

Even if you don’t take us up on our offer of a free SEO audit, we’ll just cross our fingers and hope you don’t fall prey to people who promise results so good so quickly, they’re unbelievable… because they are.

True SEO is the constant practice of matching your website’s offer to searchers’ intent. While you’ll often see a quick boost from fixing tech issues and fleshing out listings, building solid rank can often take time, focus, and some seriously relevant content. Even Google recommends waiting four months to a year before you evaluate the result of your efforts.

The SEO metric to care about isn’t necessarily “higher search volume” (although that’s nice). It’s higher search intent — meaning more of your right people are looking for you.

Because at the end of the day, the real purpose of SEO is to provide the best possible experience to human users. That’s what the robots want. And that’s what we’ll help your website do.

Here’s how we stay on top

TL;DR: we read boring documentation so you don’t have to

Search algorithms change all the time, even when those changes aren’t big and dramatic enough to make the marketing news.

Because we’re proud SEO dweebs, we regularly get deep into the weeds of trustworthy search engine sources like Search Engine Roundtable, Search Engine Journal, and yes, even Google’s own documentation — so you don’t have to. We also follow leading SEO experts and Googlers, like John Mueller and Gary Illyes, to get holistic context on upcoming changes and what they’ll mean for our clients.

Also worth noting? We do this all the time, so we can read between the lines. We know what obscure tipoffs to look for to stay ahead of the curve.

Rather not think about it?
Hand over your SE-wOes

Polymath’s SEO and marketing retainer services are custom-built based on your requirements, and on any issues we find during the audit and discovery process.

Your monthly SEO retainer is always flat-fee and agreed upon in advance — because budget surprises are nobody’s favorite.

And while this is a somewhat squishier benefit, it’s important: we’re smart and honest and you’ll genuinely enjoy working with us. So much that you might even want to play video games with us (hey, other clients are doing it)…

LET’S START WITH YOUR FREE AUDIT trending_flat No obligations, no worries, just useful takeaways